FITCH LODGE - KEY WEST HISTORIC INNS, Key West

The hotel sits on Eaton Street across from the #18 Duval loop stop, providing direct access to Key West's main thoroughfare and attractions. The ferry terminal for Dry Tortugas and Fort Jefferson is 4-5 blocks away. The neighbourhood is quiet yet central, ideal for exploring on foot or by bike. Nearby dining includes Old Town Bakery, Eaton Street Seafood Market, and numerous restaurants within a 5-minute walk. There is no on-site parking; the nearest city garage is three blocks away and costs $32-40 per night. Limited free street parking may be available but requires searching for spaces not marked as residential or permit only.

Room types available are double (1 bed), quadruple (2 beds), and suite (3 beds). All have private bathrooms, air conditioning (some units are noisy or have temperature control issues), and a mini fridge. Suites may include a kitchenette with basic utensils. Rooms are generally small and can feel humid; some have musty odours or mould in bathrooms. Noise from the street or neighbouring rooms can be an issue - road-facing rooms are particularly affected by traffic and construction. There is no coffee maker in rooms (coffee is available in the lobby), and most rooms lack a desk or chair, making work or dining in the room impractical. The property has no elevator, so rooms on upper floors are only accessible via stairs. Some suites have split-level layouts with steps between rooms. Connecting rooms and rollaway beds are not available. Balconies are not provided.

The daily resort fee includes a grab-and-go breakfast bag available in the lobby, typically containing a waffle, yogurt, banana, and a cheese/craisin/almond pack. Additionally, a discount or $10 voucher for Old Town Bakery (0.5 km away) is provided, offering excellent pastries and breakfast sandwiches. Coffee and tea are available complimentary in the lobby. There is no on-site restaurant or bar beyond the daily happy hour. Numerous dining options are within easy walking distance, including Ingrid's Key West Kitchen, Off the Hook Grill, The Dirty Pig, and Prime Steakhouse. For those in suites with kitchenettes, nearby markets supply fresh ingredients.

The pool is small but well-maintained and heated, surrounded by a courtyard with sun loungers, beach towels, and a fence. It offers a refreshing escape after exploring Key West. There is no spa or wellness centre on site. The hotel can arrange bike rentals through a partner company at a special rate, and scuba diving through a local agency. The location is ideal for walking to Duval Street, Mallory Square, and the ferry terminal. The pool area is peaceful and provides a quiet retreat.

Wi-Fi is free in all areas but can be unreliable. Free luggage storage is available if arriving before check-in or after check-out. Daily housekeeping is provided, though timing may vary. The resort fee ($45+/day) includes concierge services, in-room Wi-Fi, yoga mats, coffee/tea, daily happy hour (boozy lemonade at 3pm), and local partner perks (e.g., at Old Town Bakery and Southpoint Divers). Pets are allowed (charges may apply). The property is wheelchair accessible with grab rails in toilets, but there is no elevator - accessible rooms are on the ground floor. Payment is by major credit cards. Check-in is from 16:00, check-out by 11:00; late check-in can be arranged with advance notice. Services include invoice provision, key card access, fire extinguishers, and smoke alarms.