THE MERMAID & THE ALLIGATOR - ADULT ONLY, Key West

The property sits on Truman Avenue, a quiet residential street that is a few minutes' walk from the vibrant Duval Street area. The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum is an 8-minute walk, South Beach is less than 1 km away, and the Southernmost Point is a 13-minute stroll. Key West International Airport is 3 km from the hotel. The neighbourhood is safe and walkable; a hop-on-hop-off bus stop is nearby, and the property offers complimentary bikes for exploring. The location allows for easy access to waterfront dining and nightlife while being far enough to avoid the noise of the main strip. Parking on-site is limited to 4 vehicles, but free street parking is available, and EV chargers are on the premises.

Each room includes air conditioning (some with two units for reliable cooling), a private bathroom with shower, free toiletries, bathrobes, and a hairdryer. Rooms feature garden views, private entrances, and some offer patios, terraces, or wraparound balconies with outdoor seating. The spacious Treetop Suite and Caribbean Queen rooms provide extra space and natural light, while the Garden Room has direct ground-level access to the gardens and plunge pool. Room amenities include a work desk, wardrobe, ironing facilities, and a sitting area. The historic wooden building (built 1904) may have slight quirks typical of older properties. A communal TV and shared mini-fridge are available in the main house. Wine or champagne is offered upon arrival.

Breakfast is included in the stay and consists of a single hot entrée each morning, rotating through 9 different dishes, served in the garden patio setting with a fountain. Fresh fruit and made-to-order options are available. The property also offers a daily happy hour with wine and cheese, plus 24/7 access to coffee, tea, soft drinks, bottled water, and light snacks. Nearby dining within a 5-minute walk includes Bobby's Monkey Bar, El Siboney Restaurant, and Little Pearl. The full kitchen and dining area in the main house are available for use.

The property features a small, heated outdoor pool with jets (often described as a jacuzzi-sized plunge pool) that is open all year round. Sun loungers and beach umbrellas are provided. The landscaped garden includes a hot tub, fountain, and multiple quiet seating areas, ideal for reading or relaxation. Massages can be arranged in the garden cabana with advance booking. The adults-only policy ensures a quiet atmosphere throughout. Complimentary beach towels, coolers, and sunscreen are provided for trips to South Beach or other nearby waterfront spots.

Wi-Fi is free and available throughout the property. Services include daily housekeeping, luggage storage, private check-in/check-out, and a concierge who can assist with recommendations and reservations. A shared lounge with TV is available for use. On-site parking is limited to 4 standard vehicles plus 1 handicap space on a first-come, first-served basis; free street parking is also available. The property also has EV chargers. The facility is non-smoking with a $250 fine for violations. Safety features include key access, smoke alarms, and fire extinguishers. The historic building does not have a lift, so upper-floor rooms require stair access.