Top 18 Cheap Hotels in Montauk, 2026. Rooms from US$99/night

Good to know

Montauk, Beyond the Beach

Blufftop Park Trails
Shadmoor State Park's 2,400 feet of ocean frontage put bluff-top trails above the Atlantic, with freshwater ponds and old military bunkers along the way. Nearby 415-acre Camp Hero State Park has coastal paths through open grassland, while 862-acre Montauk Point State Park reaches the island's eastern tip. Carry water: shade is sparse on these exposed trails.
Seafood and Driftwood Ale
At Gosman's Dock, the fish market sits beside the seafood counters; Duryea's serves lobster rolls above Fort Pond Bay. Montauk Brewing Company's Driftwood Ale brings caramel-malt notes in a can to take home. Menus follow the catch, so the fish board-not a fixed dish list-is the useful clue when choosing between fluke, tuna or shellfish.
Train or Coach
The LIRR Montauk Branch ends at Montauk station, inland from the village and beaches. Buy rail tickets in MTA TrainTime before boarding; Hampton Jitney also stops in the village, so it avoids the station-to-town leg. Neither option gets you to Ditch Plains or Montauk Point, so local taxi rides matter for beach and lighthouse days.
Cast or Charter
Fall brings striped bass within reach of Montauk's surf, while charter boats target fluke and porgies in their seasons. Viking Fleet runs party-boat fishing trips; Miss Montauk II offers smaller charter outings, and Montauk Marine Basin serves private boats. Choose surfcasting for a rod-and-waders day, or sail for open-water fishing.

WINTER LOWS
- January
- February
January and February are usually the lowest-priced months: many seasonal inns close, and cold, windy beach weather limits demand. Open hotels often run $150-$300 per night on average.
SHOULDER VALUE
- May
- October
May and October bring the best value-weather balance: days are milder, but Atlantic water stays cool and crowds thin outside weekends. Typical rates are $250-$500 nightly at open properties.
SUMMER SURGE
- Memorial Day weekend
- July 4th
- Labor Day weekend
- July-August Saturdays
Memorial Day, July 4th and Labor Day weekends, plus July-August Saturdays, bring the sharpest demand. Montauk rooms often reach $600-$1,000 nightly; reserve early or shift to weekdays.

Price range for hotels in Montauk

Cheap hotels in cities across the world — search by destination, filter by price, and book the stay that fits your trip.

⬆️ The highest price

USD 322

⬇️ The lowest price

USD 99

💸 Average price for

3-star hotels

USD 181

Apartments

USD 216

Cheap hotels in Montauk worth considering

Based on guest reviews over the last 12 months

Beachfront Paradise:

Royal Atlantic Beach Resort

Charming Boutique Stay:

Hotel Corduroy

Family Friendly Retreat:

Beachcomber Resort At Montauk

Cozy Inn Experience:

Kenny'S Tipperary Inn

Relaxing Soundside Escape:

Sun And Sound Montauk

Unique Vintage Charm:

Daunts Albatross Motel

Oceanview Comfort:

Montauk Blue Hotel

Chic Coastal Living:

Breakers Montauk

Spacious Accommodations:

Apartment In Royal Atlantic Beach Resort

FAQs about hotels in Montauk

The main things you should know before booking a hotel

Which hotel properties in Montauk offer the best value for families?

For families, the Beachcomber Resort At Montauk and the Royal Atlantic Beach Resort provide spacious rooms and close proximity to the beach. Family-friendly amenities include pools and outdoor spaces. Average prices range from $200 to $400 per night during peak season.

Which Montauk hotels are best situated near popular landmarks?

The Montauk Blue Hotel is located near the Montauk Point Lighthouse, approximately 3 kilometers away. Hotel Corduroy is also well-positioned, just a 1.5-kilometer drive from the beach and local dining. Both offer convenient access to major attractions.

Are there any hotels in Montauk known for unique views?

Kenny's Tipperary Inn and Daunts Albatross Motel offer rooms with ocean views. These accommodations provide picturesque scenery that guests often highlight positively in reviews.

What are the top-rated hotels in Montauk based on guest reviews?

Top-rated properties include A Wave Inn - Montauk and Breakers Montauk. Guests frequently mention the hospitality and cleanliness, with both receiving scores above 9/10 in satisfaction ratings.

Which hotels in Montauk are ideal for couples looking for a romantic getaway?

Hotel Corduroy and Breakers Montauk are popular among couples for their serene settings and proximity to beaches, ideal for romantic evening walks. Average nightly rates for romantic stays range from $250 to $450 in peak season.

Hotel Insights for Montauk Travelers

This guide evaluates ten hotels in Montauk, providing essential information to assist travelers in making informed accommodation choices based on specific facts about pricing, location, and travel tips.

Typical nightly rates range from $150 to $600.

Montauk hosts around 10 hotels, varying from budget to luxury.

Peak seasons are June to August, with higher rates.

Local taxes and fees total approximately 15%.

Most hotels are within 1.5 km of Montauk Point Lighthouse.

Hotels in other cities in United States

New York636 properties

Rochester52 properties

Why use Cheaphotels.org?

Best Selection

Find cheap hotels for virtually any destination in the world.

Latest Montauk Hotels Deals

Find the latest hotel deals, with discounts of up to 50% off.

Lowest Rates Guaranteed

Book cheap hotels in Montauk at the lowest possible price.

18 Best Cheap Hotels in Montauk

Hotels Across Montauk, United States — Search by City, See the Full Price

Montauk, Beyond the Beach

Blufftop Park Trails

Seafood and Driftwood Ale

Train or Coach

Cast or Charter

Montauk Hotel Prices by Season

WINTER LOWS

SHOULDER VALUE

SUMMER SURGE