28 Best Cheap Hotels in Islamorada

Hotels Across Islamorada, United States — Search by City, See the Full Price

Check-in
23Nov
Check-out
24Nov
Guests
2 Guests
Islamorada is known for its beautiful beaches, like Anne's Beach and Founders Park, where you can enjoy swimming and kayaking. Try your luck at the nearby Islander Watersports for exciting water activities. When it comes to hotels with beach views, you'll find options like the Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina and the Cheeca Lodge & Spa, which offer fantastic amenities. Be sure to explore the curated selection of hotels here, noted for their reviews and stunning beachfront locations. Book early, especially in peak season, and consider renting a bike to explore the scenic paths around the area.
All filters
1-20 out of 28
Sort by:high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
8.2
Great
MapSport Fishing Capital200m
Breezy Palms Resort is a family-friendly oceanfront property in Islamorada, offering direct beach access and stunning views of the Atlantic. Guests can relax by the inviting outdoor pool and enjoy various water activities right on their doorstep. With on-site dining options and spacious rooms, it caters perfectly to leisure travelers seeking a vibrant tropical getaway.
  • Private beach
  • Outdoor pool
  • On-site dining
Oceanfront resort featuring beach access and abundant watersport activities
FromUS$ 142 /nightSelect
8.4
Great
MapBeautiful marina views300m
Sunset Inn welcomes guests to a beautifully renovated resort designed with a touch of Floridian charm. Experience a serene atmosphere with a heated outdoor pool and modern Island-themed rooms, some featuring kitchenettes for added convenience. Located within walking distance to captivating sunsets and a lovely marina, it offers an ideal base for island exploration.
  • Heated pool
  • Outdoor BBQ
  • Spacious rooms
Charming resort with contemporary design near stunning sunsets
FromUS$ 107 /nightSelect
8.4
Great
MapPrivate Beach Area800m
La Jolla Resort offers a tranquil getaway with stunning views and a private beach area. Guests can relax by the outdoor pool or engage in activities like cycling and snorkeling. Ideally located in the heart of Islamorada, the resort is close to dining, shopping, and beautiful beaches.
  • Outdoor Pool
  • Private Beach
  • Bicycle Rental
Ideal resort for beach lovers seeking adventure and relaxation.
FromUS$ 182 /nightSelect
8.0
Great
MapOceanfront Location300m
Fisher Inn Resort & Marina offers guests modern beachfront rooms with stunning ocean views and convenient amenities. Enjoy direct access to water sports, fishing, and nature activities, complemented by a heated pool and outdoor dining areas. The resort's family-friendly atmosphere and pet-friendly policies make it an ideal destination for all travelers looking to explore the Florida Keys.
  • Heated Pool
  • Boat Ramp
  • Event Space
Oceanfront resort offering unique fishing and leisure experiences in Islamorada.
FromUS$ 184 /nightSelect
8.0
Great
MapSport Fishing Capital0m
Chesapeake Beach Resort offers stunning ocean views and a relaxing atmosphere, ideal for a seaside getaway. Guests enjoy private beach access, excellent dining options, and complimentary water sports. The elegantly appointed rooms, coupled with lush landscaping, provide a perfect setting for families and vacationers looking for a memorable stay in the Florida Keys.
  • Private Beach
  • Outdoor Pool
  • Water Sports
Resort offering ocean views and extensive recreational activities in Florida Keys
FromUS$ 149 /nightSelect
8.2
Great
MapAtlantic Ocean Sunset Viewsnot specified
Pines & Palms Resort is a charming retreat situated on the stunning Atlantic Ocean, offering guests breathtaking beachfront views and a relaxing tropical atmosphere. Enjoy spacious rooms equipped with full kitchens, ideal for families looking to embrace the laid-back Florida Keys lifestyle. With a heated pool, vibrant tiki bar, and easy access to local fishing charters, guests can indulge in adventure or simply unwind in paradise.
  • Heated Pool
  • Tiki Bar
  • Fishing Charters
Boutique resort with charming cottages and scenic oceanfront access
FromUS$ 134 /nightSelect
8.4
Great
MapPrivate Beach Access0m
Matecumbe Resort offers beachfront rooms with stunning views of the ocean, perfect for leisure travelers. Enjoy a private beach area, an outdoor swimming pool, and various on-site activities like cycling and fishing. With fully equipped kitchens and barbecue facilities, guests can relish a cozy dining experience in a beautiful natural setting.
  • Private Beach
  • Outdoor Pool
  • Barbecue Area
Beachfront resort with outdoor pool and private beach area
FromUS$ 125 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good
MapDirect ocean access0m
Nestled in the heart of the Florida Keys, Hadley Resort And Marina offers stunning ocean views and direct access to top recreational activities, including fishing and boating. Guests can unwind in spacious rooms while enjoying the beautiful grounds, a heated outdoor pool, and on-site dining options. With complimentary water sports equipment and nearby attractions, this resort is an ideal destination for a delightful getaway.
  • Outdoor pool
  • On-site marina
  • Water sports
Oceanfront resort with boating and fishing adventures in the Florida Keys
FromUS$ 147 /nightSelect
8.4
Great
MapAdjacent to Windley Key Fossil Reef300m
Drop Anchor Resort & Marina offers an inviting beachfront experience ideal for leisure travelers. Guests can indulge in scenic ocean views from the pool or unwind in beautifully maintained grounds. With pet-friendly policies and easy access to local attractions, the resort delivers on comfort and convenience.
  • Saltwater Pool
  • Outdoor Dining
  • Recreational Equipment
Oceanfront resort with unique retro decor and recreational activities
FromUS$ 344 /nightSelect
8.2
Great
MapOceanfront Views50m
Sands Of Islamorada is an inviting oceanfront hotel located in the scenic Florida Keys, offering guests breathtaking views and a tranquil atmosphere. Enjoy a range of activities including fishing and diving, along with access to top-rated seafood restaurants just a stroll away. Relax by the outdoor pool or soak in the hot tub while soaking up the splendid sunsets.
  • Outdoor Pool
  • Hot Tub
  • Boat Ramp
Charming Oceanfront Hotel Embracing Old Florida Vibes
FromUS$ 200 /nightSelect
7.8
Very good
MapIdyllic Beachfront Retreat200m
Nestled in the heart of Islamorada, Coconut Cove Resort & Marina boasts a stunning 7-acre waterfront property with breathtaking ocean views. Guests indulge in a serene environment featuring a unique pool with a waterfall and a gentle beach entry, perfect for families. Enjoy on-site amenities like fishing, water sports, and exclusive wedding services surrounded by natural beauty and wildlife.
  • Waterfront Pool
  • Private Marina
  • On-site Dining
Tropical Resort Oasis with Stunning Natural Beauty and Unique Amenities
FromUS$ 189 /nightSelect
8.0
Great
MapNear Windley Key700m
The Ocean View Inn features an inviting outdoor swimming pool and a restaurant, making it a perfect retreat for leisure travelers. With comfortable rooms equipped with patios and modern amenities, guests enjoy a relaxing stay near the Gulf. The hotel's prime location offers easy access to notable attractions, enhancing your vacation experience.
  • Outdoor Pool
  • On-site Restaurant
  • Pool Bar
Hotel with Dining and Relaxation by the Gulf
FromUS$ 213 /nightSelect
8.2
Great
MapPrivate Beach Area0m
Caloosa Cove Resort offers exquisite oceanfront rooms with stunning views and fully equipped kitchens, perfect for families and couples. The resort features a beautiful heated pool, a private beach area, and on-site dining options that enhance the relaxing atmosphere. Located in the heart of the Florida Keys, guests can enjoy local dining and fishing opportunities right at their doorstep.
  • Heated Pool
  • On-site Dining
  • Private Beach
Resort with Oceanfront Rooms and Exceptional Leisure Activities
FromUS$ 414 /nightSelect
MapBeautiful Canal SettingN/A
Treasure Harbor offers a unique houseboat experience nestled in a picturesque canal setting. Guests enjoy well-appointed rooms with lake views and a range of outdoor activities, including cycling and watersports. With friendly staff and an outdoor swimming pool, it's an ideal retreat for leisure travelers seeking relaxation and adventure.
  • Outdoor Pool
  • Bicycle Rental
  • Barbecue Facilities
Hotel offering houseboat experiences and outdoor activities in a scenic setting.
FromUS$ 171 /nightSelect
8.2
Great
MapBreathtaking Ocean Views300m
Ragged Edge Resort & Marina offers a tranquil escape in Islamorada, appealing to leisure travelers with its stunning ocean views and easy access to water sports. Guests can enjoy a range of activities like fishing, kayaking, and dining at nearby seaside restaurants. With its family-oriented atmosphere and charming old-world appeal, the resort ensures a memorable stay filled with island life.
  • Outdoor Pool
  • Fishing Dock
  • Kayak Rentals
Secluded Resort Emphasizing Relaxation and Water Activities
FromUS$ 344 /nightSelect
Key Lime Cottage In The Heart Of Islamorada
MapNearby Sea Oats Beach2.6km
Key Lime Cottage offers guests a charming retreat in Islamorada, complete with a year-round outdoor pool and lush garden views. The two-bedroom, air-conditioned rooms feature modern amenities and a fully equipped kitchen, ensuring a comfortable stay. Proximity to local attractions and private parking enhance the convenience for leisure travelers.
  • Outdoor Pool
  • Private Parking
  • Garden Views
Charming holiday home with outdoor pool and garden access
FromUS$ 326 /nightSelect
Anglers Reef Vacation Rental
MapPrivate Beach Access115km
Anglers Reef Vacation Rental offers a private beach area and stunning garden views, making it a perfect getaway in Islamorada. Guests can enjoy water sports, cycling, and fishing, along with a heated saltwater pool for relaxation. The villa features modern amenities including a fully equipped kitchen and a private balcony, ensuring a comfortable stay.
  • Private Pool
  • Saltwater Pool
  • Water Sports
Luxury vacation rental with private beach and water sports
FromUS$ 365 /nightSelect
Executive Bay Islamorada By Sofla Vacations
MapPrivate Beach Access0m
Executive Bay Islamorada offers a private beach area and outdoor swimming pool, perfect for relaxation. Guests can indulge in various on-site activities including tennis and diving, while the fully equipped rooms provide all the comforts of home. Enjoy the beautiful surroundings and conveniences such as free private parking and a picnic area for leisurely family outings.
  • Outdoor Pool
  • Tennis Court
  • Picnic Area
Serene Beachfront Resort with Recreational Amenities
FromUS$ 150 /nightSelect
At The Sandbar - Oceanfront, Htd Pool, Dock, Gameroom
MapTheater of the Sea300m
At The Sandbar offers an oceanfront holiday home with breathtaking sea views, featuring three spacious rooms and three bathrooms. Guests can indulge in a heated outdoor pool, unwind at the on-site spa, or enjoy various water activities and games. Located near local attractions like Theater of the Sea, it's an ideal retreat for leisure travelers seeking relaxation and adventure.
  • Heated Pool
  • Spa Centre
  • Game Room
Oceanfront resort with extensive recreational and relaxation amenities
FromUS$ 467 /nightSelect
8.2
Great
The Caribbean Resort
MapScenic waterfront marina100m
Nestled in the heart of Islamorada, The Caribbean Resort offers stunning views and a beautiful pool area surrounded by lush landscaping. Guests can enjoy a variety of recreational activities, excellent dining options, and private rooms with full kitchens. The tranquil environment and thoughtful amenities make it an ideal retreat for families and leisure travelers alike.
  • Beautiful pool
  • Deep-water marina
  • On-site spa
Family-friendly resort with diverse recreational experiences and beautiful scenery
FromUS$ 475 /nightSelect
  • 1
  • 2

Good to know

Islamorada's Mile-Marker Keys

  • Afternoon Reef Charter

    Islamorada Dive Center's Afternoon Scuba & Snorkel Trips leave from Three Waters Marina at MM 84.5 and visit two shallow-reef sites chosen by the captain. The four-hour charter runs year-round, and snorkelers can join without certification with gear supplied. Take this guided boat trip to reach reefs offshore; no Islamorada tourist card covers it.

  • Anne's Beach and Preserves

    Anne's Beach is free to enter, with an oceanside boardwalk and shallow swimming; use its north parking area at MM 73.5 for beach access. Green Turtle Hammock Nature Preserve also has free entry, a 0.4-mile loop trail and a kayak launch to Little Basin. Key Tree Cactus Nature Preserve is another free municipal preserve, with a paved path and picnic tables; these sites offer free alternatives to Founders Park and state parks.

  • Ride Freebee

    Ride Freebee summons Islamorada's electric vehicles through its app for shared, on-demand rides around the village, rather than along a fixed bus route. The service typically runs from morning until midnight, seven days a week. Enter your pickup and drop-off in the app, or call 855-918-3733 to request a ride by phone if you cannot use it; arrange other transport for destinations outside its service area.

  • Overseas Highway Markers

    On U.S. 1, green mile-marker signs work as Islamorada's address system: the village stretches from about MM 90.9 in the north to MM 72.6 in the south, and the numbers decrease as you drive south. Add a destination's marker to your directions before setting off. Plantation Key, Windley Key, Upper Matecumbe Key and Lower Matecumbe Key all run along the Overseas Highway, so the marker is more precise than the island name alone.

1 / 4

Best Times to Find Hotel Deals in Islamorada

LAST UPDATED: 2026-09-18 14:37:52

  • LATE SUMMER

    • August
    • September

    August and September are usually the cheapest months: hot, rainy weather, hurricane risk and fading summer demand keep prices down. Typical rooms run $180-$300 nightly, before taxes and fees.

  • SHOULDER SEASON

    • May
    • November

    May and November offer the best shoulder-season tradeoff: May is warm before peak summer rain; November turns drier and cooler, with fewer winter visitors. Typical rates are $250-$400 nightly.

  • PEAK DATES

    • Winter holidays
    • Spring break
    • Lobster Mini-Season

    Winter holidays and spring break bring the sharpest room-price jumps, while July's lobster mini-season adds demand. Expect $400-$700+ nightly at peak; reserve months ahead for waterfront stays.

Major Events

January

Winter Sailfish Series Tournaments

January is peak sailfish season in the Sportfishing Capital of the World, with the Islamorada Tournament and the Cheeca Lodge Presidential Sailfish Tournament drawing sportfishing teams and typically pushing rates 30-60% higher to roughly $350-$550 per night.

May

Gold Cup Tarpon Tournament

Islamorada's spring tarpon run, capped by this historic tournament, attracts anglers from around the world and often lifts rates 30-50% to about $350-$500 per night.

June

Islamorada Dolphin Tournament

One of the Keys' biggest offshore events targets summer mahi-mahi, typically adding 20-40% to rates, or about $300-$450 per night.

Late July

Lobster Mini-Season

The two-day recreational lobster mini-season in late July brings divers and lobster hunters from across Florida, often doubling rates to $400-$600+ per night with sellouts and minimum-stay rules, and demand stays strong through the regular season opening on August 6.

November

Redbone Celebrity Tournament

This long-running celebrity fishing tournament in early November draws anglers and teams from across the country, lifting rates roughly 20-40% to about $300-$400 per night.

December

Islamorada Billfish Tournament

The annual billfish tournament kicks off the winter sportfishing season in early December, adding roughly 20-40% to rates, or around $300-$450 per night.

Late December - January 1

Christmas & New Year's Holiday Season

The holiday stretch is Islamorada's busiest and most expensive time of the year as families fill the resorts, with rates commonly 60-100% above baseline at $450-$700+ per night and multi-night minimums.

Various Throughout the Year

Recurring Fishing Tournaments & On-the-Water Events

Beyond the headline events, Islamorada hosts a steady calendar of offshore, inshore and ladies' tournaments across the seasons, which can push rates 15-30% higher to roughly $300-$400 per night.

Where to Stay in Islamorada

First time here or unsure where to stay? Compare these three areas to match your Islamorada base to your plans.

  • Most Central

    Upper Matecumbe Key

    • central
    • commercial
    • busy
    Best for
    first-time visitors, restaurant-focused trips, shoppers
    Price point
    $$-$$$ – rates are often higher near the main dining and shopping areas.
    Walkability score
    5/10 – you can walk between some Morada Way shops and restaurants, but many stops along US 1 require a car.
    Hotel highlight
    Some full-service resorts have pools, private beach areas, and on-site dining; check which amenities are included in your rate.
    Top landmark
    Morada Way Arts & Cultural District
  • Best for Nature and History

    Windley Key

    • quiet
    • wooded
    • car-dependent
    Best for
    nature-focused travelers, families visiting local attractions, anglers with a boat
    Price point
    $$-$$$ – smaller waterfront stays and resorts vary in price and amenities.
    Walkability score
    3/10 – attractions and places to eat are spread out, so plan to drive between them.
    Hotel highlight
    Some waterfront properties offer docks or fishing facilities; ask about slip fees and availability before booking.
    Top landmark
    Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park
  • Quieter South-End Stay

    Lower Matecumbe Key

    • residential
    • low-density
    • secluded
    Best for
    couples seeking a quiet stay, longer-stay visitors, beach-focused travelers
    Price point
    $$-$$$ – rates depend on how close a property is to the water and its included amenities.
    Walkability score
    3/10 – Anne's Beach is walkable from nearby stays, but most dining and errands require a car.
    Hotel highlight
    Some condo-style stays offer kitchens and multi-room layouts, which can help on longer visits.
    Top landmark
    Anne's Beach

Typical hotel prices in Islamorada

Cheap hotels in cities across the world — search by destination, filter by price, and book the stay that fits your trip.

⬆️ The highest price
USD 590
⬇️ The lowest price
USD 107
💸 Average price for
3-star hotels
USD 213

Cheap hotels in Islamorada worth considering

Reflects guest feedback from the past year

Tropical Serenity:
Breezy Palms Resort
Marina Adventures:
Fisher Inn Resort & Marina
Charming Getaway:
Sunset Inn
Beachfront Bliss:
Chesapeake Beach Resort
Family Haven:
Pines & Palms Resort
Rustic Elegance:
Hadley Resort And Marina
Hidden Gem:
Matecumbe Resort
Oceanview Retreat:
The Ocean View Inn
Luxury Escape:
Anglers Reef Paradise

Budget hotel FAQs for Islamorada

The main things you should know before booking a hotel

Which hotels in Islamorada are best for families?
Coconut Cove Resort & Marina and Chesapeake Beach Resort are great family-friendly options, featuring pools and spacious rooms suitable for families.
Are there hotels with scenic views in Islamorada?
Hotels like Breezy Palms Resort and Sunset Inn offer stunning water views, making them ideal for guests looking for picturesque settings.
Which hotels are top-rated by guests in Islamorada?
Pines & Palms Resort and Treasure Harbor have received high ratings from guests, noted for their locations and cleanliness.
What is the best hotel for couples in Islamorada?
La Jolla Resort is a recommended choice for couples, featuring romantic beach access and cozy accommodations.

Hotels Overview in Islamorada, Florida

This guide evaluates 24 hotels in Islamorada, providing key insights to help travelers choose the best accommodation for their trip.

Typical nightly rates range from $150 to $400.

Peak travel seasons are from December to April.

Local taxes and fees total approximately 12.5%.

Most hotels are within 3 km of the Florida Keys Brewing Co.

Booking in advance can secure better prices, especially during peak season.

Hotels in other cities in United States

Why use Cheaphotels.org?

Best Selection

Find cheap hotels for virtually any destination in the world.

Latest Islamorada Hotels Deals

Find the latest hotel deals, with discounts of up to 50% off.

Lowest Rates Guaranteed

Book cheap hotels in Islamorada at the lowest possible price.